The 2026 MLB All-Star Game is just around the corner, and while the voting results have been generally impressive, there are a few players who deserve more recognition. Here are 10 players who have been overlooked in the All-Star ballot, each bringing their own unique strengths to the table:
Dillon Dingler (Tigers): Dingler's defensive prowess as a catcher is well-documented, and his bat has come alive this season. With a .358/.390/.774 slash line and 16 home runs, he's a top-10 player according to FanGraphs WAR. Despite the Tigers' struggles, Dingler has been a consistent performer.
Nick Kurtz (Athletics): Kurtz, the AL Rookie of the Year in 2025, has become the face of the Athletics' success. His 48-game on-base streak and 1.243 June OPS showcase his exceptional hitting ability. While he's currently fourth among first basemen, Kurtz deserves a spot on the All-Star team.
Randy Arozarena (Rays): Arozarena has been a consistent performer for the Rays, even though they've had a surprising season. With 15 home runs and a .272/.335/.505 slash line, he's a strong candidate for the All-Star team, especially considering his performance in 2023.
Leury Garcia (White Sox): Garcia has been a key player for the White Sox, who are now competing for the AL Central title. His 11 home runs and .267/.324/.462 slash line make him a valuable contributor, and his defensive skills are often overlooked.
Hayato Montgomery (White Sox): Montgomery, who finished fifth in AL Rookie of the Year voting last season, has improved significantly this year. His defensive play and power hitting make him a strong contender for an All-Star spot.
Tom Goodman (Rockies): Goodman has been the best player on the Rockies for two straight seasons. Leading all NL catchers in homers and OPS, he's a tempting choice for voters, despite the team's recent lack of All-Star candidates.
Pat Turang (Brewers): Turang has had the best season of his career, leading second basemen in OPS. His ability to hide in plain sight, just like his team, makes him a deserving All-Star candidate.
Brian Lopez (Marlins): Lopez has emerged as a magnetic player for the Marlins, with his athleticism, high average, and stolen bases. His flamboyance on the field adds to his appeal, and he might secure a spot as the Marlins' representative.
Kyle Carroll (Nationals): Carroll has finished in the top six of NL MVP Award voting twice and made two All-Star Games. His consistent performance and defensive skills make him a strong All-Star candidate.
Juan Soto ( Padres): Soto, one of the top vote-getters at the outfield position, has been a standout performer. His athleticism and hitting ability make him a valuable asset, even though he's currently ranked lower than expected.
In conclusion, while the All-Star ballot has been impressive, these 10 players have been overlooked. It's time for fans to recognize their contributions and vote them into the All-Star Game. With the voting still open, it's not too late to make a difference and celebrate the talent that deserves more love.
